Much remains unknown regarding T follicular helper 17 (TFH17) cells commonly found in autoimmune patients. We previously showed that (and here ask why) egress of gut segmented filamentous bacteria (SFB)-induced TFH cells from Peyer's patches (PP) to systemic sites promotes arthritis. We found splenic TFH17 cells are gut derived. Functional analyses using fate-mapping mice revealed a c-Maf-dependent and SFB-induced TH17-to-TFH cell reprogramming that dominantly occurs in PPs. Unlike conventional TFH cells, TH17-derived TFH cells are highly migratory and atypically concentrated in the dark zone of germinal centers (GCs). Compared to conventional TFH cells, TH17-derived TFH cells express higher levels of TFH-associated functional molecules and more robustly conjugate with B cells. Gain- and loss-of-function studies demonstrated their dominance in promoting GC B cells and arthritis. Notably, murine gut TH17-derived TFH signatures exist in rheumatoid arthritis patients. Thus, gut T cell plasticity generates atypical, potent TFH cells promoting systemic autoimmunity.